When we review or compare products, we examine the underlying rationale driving their popularity. New diet product? Over two-thirds of U.S. adults are obese or overweight. A novel joint health solution? Seventy percent of older Americans experience joint pain. A healthier coffee alternative? Three-quarters of American adults consume coffee—some 400 million cups daily—creating a $100 billion domestic industry and nearly $500 billion globally.
So while the founders of MUDWTR and Everyday Dose created their coffee alternatives with doing “good” in mind, their pricing and marketing strategies ensure they also do “well” financially. This article compares the product offerings of MUDWTR vs. Everyday Dose to determine which is superior. First, we’ll explain mushroom coffee alternatives, their benefits, and why they’re disrupting the morning brew market.
Let’s get started!
Spoiler Alert: Our Quick Assessment
This is a comprehensive article, so for those seeking the condensed version: after comparing corporate policies, formulations, pricing, and marketing strategies, we believe Everyday Dose is the superior option for those looking to reduce their coffee consumption. While both brands share many similarities, our recommendation hinges on formulation—specifically the addition of collagen, L-Theanine, and amino acids in Everyday Dose’s Mud Latte.
For those interested in understanding mushroom coffee’s popularity and benefits, plus learning more about these brands, we encourage you to continue reading.
Beans or Shrooms?
What exactly is mushroom coffee? It’s a blend of ground mushrooms and coffee beans combined to brew a dark, smooth, nutty beverage with less caffeine than regular coffee. Coffee made from mushroom varieties tastes remarkably similar to traditional coffee—it’s less acidic with even greater health benefits. That’s because mushrooms provide fiber, vitamins, minerals, natural antioxidants, and polyphenols. While lower in caffeine than regular coffee, mushroom coffee still contains significantly more than decaffeinated varieties.
Although our subject brands launched recently—MUDWTR in 2018 and Everyday Dose in 2020—we don’t view mushroom coffee as merely another fad. The brew has been a Finnish staple for generations, and Starbucks is now testing mushroom blend coffee in select locations.
Mushroom coffee typically features medicinal rather than culinary mushrooms. The most common varieties are lion’s mane, reishi, turkey tail, cordyceps, and chaga. Mushrooms have served medicinal purposes for thousands of years, offering benefits as antioxidants, anti-inflammatories, and antimicrobials. They boost immune function, provide anti-tumor effects, reduce stress, and even combat cancer cells. We’ll detail the health benefits of different varieties in the formulation section.
Mushroom coffee represents a relatively new U.S. market segment that provides coffee’s benefits without the adverse effects of dependency, anxiety, nervousness, and sleep disorders.
MUDWTR vs. Everyday Dose: The Companies
MUDWTR
MUDWTR operates primarily as a direct-to-consumer, subscription-based online company. While gaining distribution in smaller health-niche stores, the product isn’t yet available on other e-commerce sites or in big box retailers.
Shane Heath founded the company in 2018 after discovering masala chai—a combination of tea, milk, and spices—during an artist residency in Goa, India. He created MUDWTR, an organic coffee alternative made with spices, mushrooms, and cacao, to address his personal caffeine challenges and dependency. Now he’s sharing it globally.
Beyond the basic MUDWTR, the company offers additional varieties—:matcha, :rest, and :gold—plus add-ins and sweeteners. Note that the () and (:) in company and product names are correct, as shown on the website and packaging.
Klauber and Company, Inc. – Everyday Dose
Everyday Dose is owned by privately held startup Klauber and Company, founded in 2020. Company founder Jack Klauber developed its coffee alternative, Mushroom Latte, to break his personal Adderall and caffeine dependency.
Everyday Dose operates an online, direct-to-consumer, subscription-based model. The product is available on Amazon.com but not in traditional brick-and-mortar retailers. The company adheres to National Institute of Health standards, and ingredients undergo third-party lab testing for quality and purity.
MUDWTR vs. Everyday Dose: The Products
MUDWTR
MUDWTR is a coffee alternative consisting of organic ingredients, including mushrooms, cacao, spices, masala chai black tea, and Himalayan pink salt. The product promises natural energy and focus, immune system support, and enhanced physical performance without jitters and crashes. The taste is described as earthy with a hint of chocolate and mild spiciness. Ingredients are USDA Organic certified, non-GMO, gluten- and sugar-free, vegan, Keto Friendly, and Kosher, with about 35 mg of caffeine per serving. Mushrooms are sourced domestically from California, using both mycelial biomass and fruiting bodies. All ingredients undergo third-party testing.
The MUDWTR Starter Kit includes a thirty-day supply of :rise, a free electronic “frother” called the Mud Whip, a guidebook, and samples of the brand’s coconut creamer and sweetener.
The recommended dosage is one 6-gram tablespoon.
Everyday Dose – the Mushroom Latte
The Mushroom Latte blends medicinal mushrooms, nootropics, collagen, L-Theanine, and low-acidity coffee extract. The company claims the product tastes like delicious coffee with 80% less caffeine—about 39 mg per cup. It’s perfect for people who love their cup of joe but hate the jitters, anxiety, digestive issues, and crash that follow regular coffee.
With its functional ingredients, Mushroom Latte combines five products: coffee, vitamins, minerals, amino acids, and protein. Ingredients are USDA Organic certified, featuring grass-fed collagen protein, trademarked L-Theanine (Suntheanine), and organic, fair-trade coffee extract. Everyday Dose is gluten-free, dairy-free, non-GMO, Paleo and Keto-friendly, and Kosher.
The product undergoes rigorous third-party testing for purity. The recommended dosage is one 6-gram tablespoon.
MUDWTR vs. Everyday Dose: Nutrition Facts Table
Both products recommend a six-gram tablespoon per serving, delivering the following nutritionals. The key difference is the protein content (collagen) in Mushroom Latte:
| MUDWTR | Mushroom Latte | |
| Calories | 20 | 20 |
| Total Fat | .5 gm | 0 gm |
| Sodium | 10 mg | 19 mg |
| Total Carbohydrates | 4 gm | 1 gm |
| Dietary Fiber | 1 gm | |
| Total Sugar | 0 gm | 0 gm |
| Protein | < 1 gm | 4 gm |
| Potassium | 110 mg | |
| Iron | .4 mg |
MUDWTR vs. Everyday Dose: The Formulations
We’ll first review the two mushroom varieties shared by both brands, address the crucial differences in their blends, and finally examine compounds unique to each brand.
Organic Chaga Mushrooms – Health benefits: Supports immune system, antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, anti-viral, and prebiotic properties.
Organic Lion’s Mane – Health benefits: Enhances cognition by improving memory, focus, and clarity. Adaptogenic properties reduce depression and anxiety while enhancing mood and creativity. Supports digestive health as a prebiotic for healthy gut flora.
Everyday Dose emphasizes their mushrooms come from fruiting bodies versus the mycelium used in MUDWTR. While both fruiting bodies and mycelium contain valuable compounds for extracts, fruiting bodies may offer slightly higher concentrations.
Another significant difference: Dose blends their mushrooms with Fair-Trade, Organic Coffee, while MUD’s blend uses Organic Masala Chai black tea.
MUDWTR – Unique Ingredients
Organic Reishi Mushrooms – Health benefits: Immune support, energy, cognition, anti-inflammatory, adaptogenic (stress relief), and prebiotic properties.
Organic Cordyceps Mushrooms – Health benefits: Energy production, endurance, and stamina enhancement.
Organic Cacao – The seeds that create chocolate, cocoa, and coconut butter. Provides flavor and health benefits through antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties.
Masala Chai – A blend of organic black tea powder and organic spices.
Organic Spice Blend – Contains all organic spices: cinnamon, turmeric, ginger, cardamom, nutmeg, black pepper, and cloves.
Organic Black Tea – A potent polyphenol with antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties. Interestingly, black tea naturally contains L-Theanine, a compound prominently featured in Everyday Dose. Additional benefits include heart health, digestive health, and reduced “bad” cholesterol.
Himalayan Pink Salt – Supports hydration and contains essential minerals the body needs.
Everyday Dose Mushroom Latte – Unique Ingredients
Organic Fair-Trade Coffee – A low-acidity extract providing 39 mg of caffeine per serving. Health benefits: increased energy, enhanced cognition, and antioxidant properties.
Collagen Peptides, 4 mg – Types I and III collagen sourced from grass-fed cows. Health benefits: improved skin, hair, nails, and joint health.
L-Theanine, 150 mg – Mushroom Latte contains a patented form of L-Theanine called Suntheanine. This amino acid found naturally in tea offers cognitive benefits and adaptogenic properties.
Amino Acid Blend – Contains nineteen amino acids, including eight essential amino acids. Health benefits: As protein’s building blocks, amino acids are crucial for muscle development and repair, plus many other vital body functions including mood and digestion.
How to Use Mushroom Coffees
As noted in the product descriptions, both brands recommend six grams added to hot water and served to taste. Both offer a “frother” to aid in blending your brew, and MUDWTR suggests adding creamer, honey, butter, or whatever enhances the flavor for you.
Benefits of Mushroom Coffee
Both brands emphasize the following benefits of mushroom coffee alternatives:
- Energy Boost
- Cognition
- Digestion/Gut Health
- Stamina
- Sleep Quality
- Supports Immune Function
- Heart Health
- No Anxiety/Jitters
- No Crash
- Non-Addictive
Everyday Dose extends their claims further, attributable to the collagen in their product that improves hair, skin, nails, and joint health.
MUDWTR vs. Everyday Dose: Price Comparisons
One general note applies equally to both MUDWTR and Everyday Dose: buyer beware, as the heavily promoted Starter Kits convert to longer-term commitments. Both companies specialize in subscription services—automatic, monthly deliveries once you access the Starter Kit offer.
MUDWTR Pricing
The MUDWTR Starter Kit costs $40 on the company website and includes a thirty-day serving, a free rechargeable frother, a guidebook, a free sticker, samples of the company’s creamer and sweetener—and a refill shipment in three weeks. Free shipping in the U.S. and a thirty-day guarantee for unopened products.
A single thirty-day supply is listed on the site at $1.33-$1.66 per serving.
Everyday Dose Pricing
Their VIP Starter Kit retails on the site for $45 and includes a thirty-serving trial, a glass vessel to store your Everyday Dose, a mug, a scooper, a motivational art poster, and a sample of their Matcha+ product—plus a refill order in thirty days for $39.99. Free shipping. Sixty-day guarantee.
A one-time purchase option is also available for $60.00 for a thirty-day supply. The starter kit is also available on Amazon.com.
MUDWTR vs. Everyday Dose: What Customers Say About the Products
MUDWTR
The company cites over thirty thousand reviews on its site, with an overall rating of 4.5 out of five stars. Unfortunately, we couldn’t validate the rating on a more unbiased platform like Amazon.com, as the product isn’t available there. Most reviewers mentioned taste, energy boost, and improved cognition, focusing on the lack of jitters or crashes.
Everyday Dose
Launched two years after MUD, Mushroom Latte has only about 1,400 reviews on its site. The company doesn’t publish an overall rating; however, reviewers mentioned energy boosts, improved mood and focus, fewer digestive issues, and enhanced skin appearance.
Everyday Dose is sold on Amazon; however, it has very few reviews, averaging 4.5 out of 5 stars.
MUD/WTR vs. Everyday Dose: For Your Consideration
How do you decide which coffee alternative suits you? Either product works as a substitute if you’re sensitive to caffeine or developing dependency. From a taste perspective, Everyday Dose is preferred by reviewers who’ve tried both products. Everyday Dose remains more faithful to the coffee concept by blending coffee with mushrooms versus the black tea in MUDWTR.
Either way, prepare for an adjustment period as you reduce caffeine consumption. Additives like coconut or almond milk should make the flavor transition more tolerable. Another option for coffee lovers who tolerate caffeine well is adding multi-collagen protein to their traditional morning cup.
In Our Opinion: MUDWTR vs. Everyday Dose
Both products deliver energy and other promised benefits without the jitters or crashes from regular coffee. Since taste is highly subjective, we focused on formulations in our decision-making process.
We were favorably impressed with the diverse organic mushroom blend in MUDWTR. We acknowledge the energy and focus benefits of Chai Tea in MUDWTR and appreciate its Organic Spice Blend, featuring ingredients commonly used in today’s popular cognition products. While MUDWTR merits consideration if you’re trying to reduce coffee consumption, it comes at a premium price.
Everyday Dose also serves as a valuable alternative for caffeine-sensitive consumers. We consider this the better-formulated option with its Fair-Trade Organic Coffee, collagen peptides, amino acid stack, and trademarked L-Theanine. It provides the same energy without jitters, but with greater potential health benefits.
